IndyCar News: Michael Andretti Lists Geist Reservoir Estate for $11.95 Million
In the high-octane world of IndyCar racing, where split-second decisions define legacies, Michael Andretti has always been a force of unyielding precision. The son of Formula One icon Mario Andretti, Michael carved his own path as a champion driver and visionary team owner, amassing a net worth north of $40 million through sheer grit and innovation.
–by Mark Cipolloni–
But now, at a crossroads in his storied career, Andretti is passing the baton on one of his most personal triumphs: a sprawling lakeside estate on Indiana’s Geist Reservoir, freshly listed for $11.95 million. It’s not just a home—it’s a testament to transformation, much like the race cars he’s tuned to perfection.
Nestled on 5.23 private, gated acres with an enviable 570 feet of pristine shoreline, the Andretti Estate sprawls across more than 21,000 square feet of architectural poetry. What began as a modest 10,000-square-foot lakeside retreat in 1990—crafted by the firm GunnSmith and later expanded to 14,000 square feet in 1999—found its true soul when the Andrettis acquired it in 2017.
Over the next three years, under the guidance of builder Rob Annee of The Palladium Group, they orchestrated a symphony of demolition, reconstruction, and reinvention. Walls came down, wings unfurled, and modern marvels wove seamlessly into the timeless bones of the original design.
“When Michael and his family purchased it, the home was already remarkable—but they took it to a whole new level,” recalls Joel Woelfle, the listing broker with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty, who had the rare honor of representing the property in an earlier chapter of its life.
This isn’t mere grandeur; it’s the largest residence ever to grace the Geist Reservoir listings, a Midwestern unicorn blending scale, serenity, and speed-demon sensibilities. Step through the grand entry, and you’re enveloped by nine bedrooms, nine full baths, and three half baths, each whisper of luxury amplified by seven crackling fireplaces—one on nearly every level for those crisp Indiana evenings. Laundry rooms dot the floors like pit stops, a residential elevator hums silently between them, and 13 HVAC systems whisper cool comfort year-round, backed by a whole-house generator that never leaves you in the dark.
For the gearhead in Andretti’s blood, there’s a 5,500-square-foot climate-controlled garage sanctuary, boasting over a dozen bays, bespoke cabinetry, and direct links to the home’s wings—a collector’s dream where Ferraris could rub fenders with family sedans.
The heart of the estate pulses in its Owner’s Wing, a secluded aerie where Geist’s glassy waters unfold like an endless straightaway. Here, mornings dawn in a sun-drenched reading nook and coffee perch, the double-sided fireplace casting a golden glow across the kingly bedroom.
The spa-like bath, crowned by a shimmering glass-tiled barrel vault, feels like a victory lap in marble and steam—pure, unadulterated retreat. Venture to the Guest Wing, a self-contained 1,700-square-foot haven with its own great room, full kitchen, two en-suite bedrooms, laundry, and garage portal, ensuring visitors feel like VIPs, not intruders.
But it’s the Lower Level that revs up the entertainment engine, transforming the estate into a private playground rivaling any speedway lounge. Imagine sinking into a 15-seat bar, uncorking from the 700-bottle climate-controlled wine cellar, then retreating to the home theater for race replays or the arcade for nostalgic duels. A fitness center gleams with mirrored walls and top-tier gear, while the billiards nook invites friendly wagers under vaulted ceilings. Four additional bedrooms and five baths ensure the party never sleeps, with multiple glass doors spilling out to the pool terrace—a seamless blend of club cool and family warmth.
Outdoors, the magic multiplies under Indiana’s vast skies. Manicured lawns roll into whispering wooded trails, where bald eagles might soar overhead as you stroll. The crown jewel is the 50-foot heated gunite pool, alive with cascading waterfalls, a bubbling jacuzzi, and fire pits that dance against the dusk.
Lounge on expansive verandas or covered terraces, dock your boat at the three-slip pier, or let the kids claim the heated play cottage as their kingdom.
Commercial-grade turf keeps the grounds pristine and goose-free, while a 2023-vintage Carriage House—tucked near the gated entrance—offers two standalone 900-square-foot apartments, each a mini-estate with kitchens, living spaces, bedrooms, baths, laundries, and two-car garages. Perfect for in-laws, staff, or that weekend crew crashing after a long haul from the track. And for those dreaming bigger, full blueprints await for a 4,400-square-foot Sports Building addition, ready to crown the compound with tennis courts or a home-circuit simulator.
“This is a property of true scale and grandeur, combining size, luxury, and waterfront amenities in a way rarely seen,” says co-listing agent Allen Williams, his voice laced with awe. “The Andretti Estate perfectly captures luxury living—where innovation meets serenity. It’s a home built for connection, reflection, and entertainment. Properties of this caliber are rare in the Midwest.”
As Andretti eyes new horizons—this Geist gem stands poised for its next chapter. Is it a tech mogul seeking a quiet empire? A fellow racing dynasty ready to hoist the flag? Whatever the story’s next twist, it’s clear: this isn’t just a sale; it’s the handover of a legacy etched in stone, steel, and shimmering water.
Dive into the virtual gallery and tour at AndrettiEstate.com.
Private showings? Reach Joel Woelfle at joel@bhhsin.com or (317) 590-8200, or Allen Williams at awilliams@bhhsin.com or (317) 339-2256.
The green light is on—who’s taking the pole?
